How a clear purpose can help you make the most of problem-solving activities in maths

Explore how to choose and use maths problem-solving tasks with a clear purpose.
Author
Grace Coker
Grace Coker
Content and Engagement Specialist (Mathematics)

Grace Coker is the EEF’s Content Specialist for Mathematics. In this blog, she explores the importance of considering the purpose when selecting problem solving tasks for pupils.

Blogs •3 minutes •

We know problem solving should be an integral part of the maths curriculum. Pupils at all levels of attainment should be supported to develop their problem-solving skills.

Embedding problem solving in maths teaching helps pupils understand that mathematical thinking goes beyond following set procedures. It can help to develop pupils’ confidence to apply their understanding to unfamiliar situations.

Fortunately, maths teachers have a plethora of potential problems to choose from. But when designing lessons or a series of maths lessons, it’s important to think about the purpose of the problem when it comes to choosing one over another.

Consider the following problem. How and why would you choose and use this mathematical problem?

Consider the following problem. How and why would you choose and use this mathematical problem?

Problem 5a

Maths Horizons, 2026

A teacher may choose to use this problem to spark curiosity and enjoyment of maths. Instead, it could be an opportunity to develop pupils’ mathematical reasoning skills. Alternatively, it could be a perfect problem to develop the strategy of working systematically. Then again, it could be a mixture of all these things.

Decisions, decisions

Teachers are continually making decisions, and when it comes to designing lessons, it is no different.

The decision around the purpose can often depend on these three Ps:

  • The pupils you teach
  • The prior knowledge they have, and
  • The point in the learning journey.

The three Ps in action

Miss Smith, a Year 2 teacher, used this problem with her pupils. She knew that when the class had previously approached these ​‘combination’ type problems they had done so in an ad-hoc ​‘trial and error’ manner. She wanted to use this opportunity to think about the problem-solving strategy of ​‘working systematically.’

She knew this would be an accessible problem for all pupils as they were drawing on familiar mathematical content and contexts – the quantity of five, and a tower of cubes.

Pupils had access to plenty of cubes and were able to work with a partner to tackle the task.

Because Miss Smith had decided a clear purpose for the problem when designing this lesson, she was able to focus on observing the pairs and listening carefully to their conversations with ​‘working systematically’ in mind.

She took photographs of particular pupils’ work and used these in a debrief session partway through.

Frame 6

Comparing and reflecting on the different ways pupils had approached the problem so far allowed Miss Smith to draw out the positives with pupils of working systematically – to ensure no combination was missed out or repeated.

At this point in the lesson, Miss Smith explained the purpose to pupils – to think about the strategy of ​‘working systematically.’

Pupils were then given time to continue to work with their partner creating other combinations and working in a systematic manner.

Throughout this lesson, Miss Smith noticed pupils also developed their reasoning skills, communicated mathematically and enjoyed working collaboratively.

She hoped highlighting the idea of ​‘working systematically’ at this point in their learning journey would prove fruitful moving forward.

Three things to consider

When making decisions and designing lessons in the future, you may want to think:

  • Have you considered the purpose when choosing and using a mathematical problem?
  • Have you considered the pupils, their prior knowledge and the point in their mathematical learning journey?
  • Have you considered whether the purpose should be communicated with pupils?

Further reading
Education Endowment Foundation. (2017). Improving mathematics in Key Stages 2 and 3, pp. 14 – 15. Available at: EEF-Improving-Mathematics-in-Key-Stages-2-and‑3 – 2022-Update.pdf