New EEF guidance report published: Improving Secondary Science

Seven practical recommendations focused on improving science teaching, particularly for disadvantaged pupils

Almost all pupils develop their own explanations for science concepts before they learn about them in lessons. 

But their ideas about things like ‘how plants grow’ or ‘how we see things’ don’t always align with scientific understanding, according to new guidance for improving science teaching published today by the Education Endowment Foundation (EEF). 

However, the report suggests that teachers can harness these common misconceptions to improve pupils’ learning.

EEF Blog: Implementing cognitive science strategies in the classroom

EEF Blog: Implementing cognitive science strategies in the classroom

EEF blog: Accelerated reader – what does the research tell us?

EEF blog: Accelerated reader – what does the research tell us?

EEF publishes two new evaluation reports

EEF publishes two new evaluation reports

Guest Blog: Retrieval practice - A common good or just commonplace?

Guest Blog: Retrieval practice - A common good or just commonplace?

New episode of ‘Evidence into Action’ – ‘Teacher Feedback to Improve Pupil Learning’

New episode of ‘Evidence into Action’ – ‘Teacher Feedback to Improve Pupil Learning’

EEF Blog: Integrating evidence into mathematics teaching – Focus on feedback

EEF Blog: Integrating evidence into mathematics teaching – Focus on feedback

New: What do we really know about cognitive science in the classroom? EEF publishes new review of the evidence

New: What do we really know about cognitive science in the classroom? EEF publishes new review of the evidence

EEF Blog: New ‘Voices from the classroom’ - Applying Rosenshine’s principles to remote learning

EEF Blog: New ‘Voices from the classroom’ - Applying Rosenshine’s principles to remote learning

EEF Blog: New case studies - Making effective use of diagnostic assessment

EEF Blog: New case studies - Making effective use of diagnostic assessment

EEF Blog: ECF– Exploring the Evidence: Prior knowledge and Pupil Misconceptions

EEF Blog: ECF– Exploring the Evidence: Prior knowledge and Pupil Misconceptions

EEF Blog: Three keys to unlocking positive learning behaviours

Kirsten Mould explains how schools might tackle the implementation challenge of building effective learning behaviours.

EEF Blog: Three keys to unlocking positive learning behaviours

EEF Blog: ECF – Exploring the Evidence: ‘Adaptive Teaching’ and Effective Diagnostic Assessment

EEF Blog: ECF – Exploring the Evidence: ‘Adaptive Teaching’ and Effective Diagnostic Assessment

EEF publishes findings from ‘Big Lockdown-Learning Parent Survey’

EEF publishes findings from ‘Big Lockdown-Learning Parent Survey’

New EEF podcast: Developing Oral Language

New EEF podcast: Developing Oral Language

EEF Blog: Integrating evidence into mathematics teaching – Guiding problem solving

EEF Blog: Integrating evidence into mathematics teaching – Guiding problem solving

EEF Blog: Phonics - mastering the basics of reading

EEF Blog: Phonics - mastering the basics of reading

EEF Blog: Assess, adjust, adapt – what does adaptive teaching mean to you?

EEF Blog: Assess, adjust, adapt – what does adaptive teaching mean to you?

EEF publishes new research on the impact of the pandemic on Key Stage 1 pupils’ attainment

EEF publishes new research on the impact of the pandemic on Key Stage 1 pupils’ attainment

EEF Blog: New ‘Voices from the classroom’ - Delivering feedback after exam practice

EEF Blog: New ‘Voices from the classroom’ - Delivering feedback after exam practice

EEF Blog: Teaching reading - Embedding comprehension strategies

EEF Blog: Teaching reading - Embedding comprehension strategies

EEF publishes findings from systematic review of attainment measures

EEF publishes findings from systematic review of attainment measures

EEF Blog: Integrating evidence into mathematics teaching – Making use of manipulatives

EEF Blog: Integrating evidence into mathematics teaching – Making use of manipulatives

How to use the Attainment Measures Database

How to use the Attainment Measures Database

Young Children’s Achievement Test – Second Edition

Young Children’s Achievement Test – Second Edition

York Assessment of Reading for Comprehension – Secondary Set

York Assessment of Reading for Comprehension – Secondary Set

York Assessment of Reading for Comprehension – Early Years Set

York Assessment of Reading for Comprehension – Early Years Set

York Assessment of Reading for Comprehenion: Primary

York Assessment of Reading for Comprehenion: Primary

Woodcock Reading Mastery Tests – Third Edition

Woodcock Reading Mastery Tests – Third Edition

Writing Assessment Tasks

Writing Assessment Tasks

Wide Range Achievement Test – Fifth Edition

Wide Range Achievement Test – Fifth Edition

Wide Range Achievement Test – Fourth Edition

Wide Range Achievement Test – Fourth Edition

Wide Range Achievement Test – Expanded

Wide Range Achievement Test – Expanded

Word Recognition and Phonic Skills Test

Word Recognition and Phonic Skills Test

The WORD Test 3 – Elementary

The WORD Test 3 – Elementary

The WORD Test 2 – Adolescent

The WORD Test 2 – Adolescent

Woodcock-Muñoz Language Survey

Woodcock-Muñoz Language Survey

Word Identification and Spelling Test

Word Identification and Spelling Test

Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children – Fourth UK Edition

Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children – Fourth UK Edition

Wechsler Individual Achievement Test – Third Edition

Wechsler Individual Achievement Test – Third Edition

Wechsler Individual Achievement Test – Second UK Edition for Teachers

Wechsler Individual Achievement Test – Second UK Edition for Teachers

Wechsler Individual Achievement Test – Second UK Edition

Wechsler Individual Achievement Test – Second UK Edition

White Rose Maths

White Rose Maths

Collins Maths Progress Tests for White Rose (Year 1–6/P2–7)

Collins Maths Progress Tests for White Rose (Year 1–6/P2–7)

Writing Assessment Measure

Writing Assessment Measure

Test of Written Spelling – Fifth Edition

Test of Written Spelling – Fifth Edition

Tutors’ Guild Year Six Mathematics Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild Year Six Mathematics Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild Year Six English Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild Year Six English Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild Edexcel GCSE (9-1) Mathematics Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild Edexcel GCSE (9-1) Mathematics Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild Edexcel GCSE (9-1) English Language Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild Edexcel GCSE (9-1) English Language Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild AQA GCSE (9-1) Mathematics Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild AQA GCSE (9-1) Mathematics Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild AQA GCSE (9-1) English Language Tutor Assessment Pack

Tutors’ Guild AQA GCSE (9-1) English Language Tutor Assessment Pack

The Trouble with Maths

The Trouble with Maths

More Trouble with Maths

More Trouble with Maths

Test of Written Language – Fourth Edition

Test of Written Language – Fourth Edition

Test of Silent Word Reading Fluency – Second Edition

Test of Silent Word Reading Fluency – Second Edition

Test of Silent Reading Efficiency and Comprehension

Test of Silent Reading Efficiency and Comprehension

Test of Silent Contextual Reading Fluency – Second Edition

Test of Silent Contextual Reading Fluency – Second Edition

Test of Reading Comprehension – Fourth Edition

Test of Reading Comprehension – Fourth Edition

Test of Phonological Awareness – Second Edition: Plus

Test of Phonological Awareness – Second Edition: Plus

Test of Mathematical Abilities – Third Edition

Test of Mathematical Abilities – Third Edition

Test of Orthographic Competence

Test of Orthographic Competence

Test of Adolescent and Adult Language – Fourth Edition

Test of Adolescent and Adult Language – Fourth Edition

Test of Irregular Word Reading Efficiency

Test of Irregular Word Reading Efficiency

The Shanghai Maths Project – Practice Books For the English National Curriculum (Years 7–10)

The Shanghai Maths Project – Practice Books For the English National Curriculum (Years 7–10)

Test of Early Written Language – Third Edition

Test of Early Written Language – Third Edition

Test of Early Reading Ability – Fourth Edition

Test of Early Reading Ability – Fourth Edition

Test of Early Mathematics Ability – Third Edition

Test of Early Mathematics Ability – Third Edition

Single Word Spelling Test

Single Word Spelling Test

Single Word Reading Test

Single Word Reading Test

Spot the Word – Second Edition

Spot the Word – Second Edition

Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scales – Fifth Edition

Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scales – Fifth Edition

Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scales – Fifth Edition for Early Childhood

Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scales – Fifth Edition for Early Childhood

Social Skills Improvement System Rating Scales

Social Skills Improvement System Rating Scales

Social Skills Improvement System Performance Screening Guide

Social Skills Improvement System Performance Screening Guide

Social Skills Improvement System Classwide Intervention Program

Social Skills Improvement System Classwide Intervention Program

Snap Science – Years 1–6

Snap Science – Years 1–6

Sigma Science Assessment

Sigma Science Assessment

Shaywitz Dyslexia Screen

Shaywitz Dyslexia Screen

Symbol Digit Modalities Test

Symbol Digit Modalities Test

Scottish Heinemann Maths

Scottish Heinemann Maths

Science Knowledge Questionnaire Year 4 (Pre-test) and Year 5 (Post-test)

Science Knowledge Questionnaire Year 4 (Pre-test) and Year 5 (Post-test)

Science Assessment Series 1 and 2 – Tailored Extracts

Science Assessment Series 1 and 2 – Tailored Extracts

Screening Assessment for Gifted Elementary and Middle School Students – Third Edition

Screening Assessment for Gifted Elementary and Middle School Students – Third Edition

Screening Assessment for Gifted Elementary and Middle School Students – Second Edition

Screening Assessment for Gifted Elementary and Middle School Students – Second Edition

Reading Milestones Placement and Monitoring

Reading Milestones Placement and Monitoring

REVISE AQA AS/A Level Biology, Chemistry and Physics Exam Skills Builder with ActiveBook

REVISE AQA AS/A Level Biology, Chemistry and Physics Exam Skills Builder with ActiveBook

Revise 11+ Maths

Revise 11+ Maths

Revise 11+ English

Revise 11+ English

Real-World Writing

Real-World Writing

Real-World Vocabulary

Real-World Vocabulary

Real-World Math

Real-World Math

Reading Detectives

Reading Detectives

Rapid Reading

Rapid Reading

Rapid Automatized Naming and Rapid Alternating Stimulus Tests

Rapid Automatized Naming and Rapid Alternating Stimulus Tests

Question Bank

Question Bank

Pictorial Test of Intelligence – Second Edition

Pictorial Test of Intelligence – Second Edition

Rising Stars Progress Tests Science – Second Edition

Rising Stars Progress Tests Science – Second Edition

Rising Stars Progress Tests Reading – Second Edition

Rising Stars Progress Tests Reading – Second Edition

Test of Word Reading Efficiency – Second Edition

Test of Word Reading Efficiency – Second Edition

Rising Stars Progress Tests Mathematics – Second Edition

Rising Stars Progress Tests Mathematics – Second Edition

According to the 'Improving Secondary Science' report, put together by a panel of teachers and leading experts, teachers should have a clear understanding of the common misconceptions in the area they’re teaching so that they know the issues that are likely to be problematic for their pupils. Teachers should also work to uncover the specific misconceptions their pupils hold through class and group discussion, before moving on to challenge these.

While these preconceptions can be hard to shift, presenting pupils with compelling evidence that contradicts them can be a good way to move thinking on. For example, many pupils find it hard to understand that the space between gas particles is empty and will often say it is filled with ‘air’, ‘dust’, or ‘bacteria’. However, showing that it is possible to compress a gas, for example by pushing down a syringe, is a good way of opening a discussion about what this means about the spaces between gas particles.

Building on pupils’ preconceptions is one of seven recommendations in today’s report designed to support secondary schools to provide every pupil – but particularly those from disadvantaged homes - with a high-quality and well-rounded grounding in science and an interest that may lead them to further study. Improving Secondary Science reviews the best available research to offer science teachers practical classroom suggestions.

Previous research by the EEF and the Royal Society found that there is a gap in science outcomes between disadvantaged pupils and their classmates at every stage in the education system. The gap first becomes apparent at Key Stage 1 (ages 5-7) and only gets wider throughout primary and secondary school and on to A-level.

This earlier research found that it is not lack of motivation to learn science that is contributing to the attainment gap between disadvantaged pupils and their better-off classmates. Analysis of attainment data found that the biggest predictors of pupils’ attainment in science are their levels of literacy and their scientific reasoning ability.

A second recommendation in today’s report focuses on developing pupils’ scientific vocabulary to support them to read and write about science. According to the report, “learning science involves learning a whole new language and it is important that you develop pupils’ fluency in that language.”

While pupils need to learn scientific words like photosynthesis or carbon dioxide, they struggle most with familiar words that have a different meaning in science. The report recommends that pupils are explicitly taught words that have a different meaning in science - like valid, random or spontaneous – so that they can understand and interpret scientific texts.

The other five recommendations focus on:

  • Using models to develop understanding
  • Developing children’s abilities to self-regulate aspects of their learning.
  • Supporting pupils’ memory skills, so that they can retain and retrieve knowledge.
  • Using experiments purposefully.
  • Using structured feedback to move on pupils’ thinking.

Sir Kevan Collins, Chief Executive of the Education Endowment Foundation, said:

Many pupils come up with their own explanations for the science concepts they meet on a daily basis, before they learn about them school. While these misconceptions are often difficult to shift, teachers can use them to challenge their pupils. Giving them compelling evidence that contradicts their own ideas can be a great way of boosting learning.

This is one of seven practical recommendations in today’s report focused on improving science teaching, particularly for disadvantaged pupils. The attainment gap in science may not be as well-documented as the gap in English and maths, but our earlier research has shown that it’s just as pervasive

Notes to editors

  1. The Education Endowment Foundation (EEF) is a grant-making charity set up in 2011 by the Sutton Trust as lead foundation in partnership with Impetus Trust (now part of Impetus–The Private Equity Foundation), with a £125m founding grant from the Department for Education. The EEF is dedicated to breaking the link between family income and educational achievement. Since its launch the EEF has awarded £96 million to test the impact of 160 projects reaching over 10,000 schools, nurseries and colleges across England, and involving more than one million children and young people. The EEF and Sutton Trust are, together, the government-designated What Works Centre for Education.
  2. The full report will be available here, from 0001 on Friday 21 September 2018.